BEFORE OCTOBER 7: PART TWO, 1948

War and Nakba

THE FIGHTING BEGINS

The fighting began within days of the vote. The United Nations Palestine Commission reported on January 26, 1948 that violent conflict between the two communities had intensified since early December. It cited general insecurity.

The commission recorded the positions of both sides. The Arab Higher Committee refused to take part. It said it was determined to persist in its rejection of partition and would not recognize United Nations resolutions. Moshe Shertok of the Jewish Agency told the commission that partition was a compromise. He pledged Jewish cooperation and asked for an international force.

Britain kept its authority in Palestine until May 15. It rejected the General Assembly’s request to evacuate a Jewish port area by February 1, citing security. British officials warned the commission that its arrival would be the signal for widespread Arab attacks on Jews and on the commission’s members.

At least 1,256 Jews were killed between November 29, 1947 and May 15, 1948. The count draws on the historians Benny Morris and Martin Gilbert, among others. Sixty-two Jews were killed in the first week after the vote. The incidents included the cutting of Jerusalem’s water supply, attacks on Negev villages and attacks in mixed neighborhoods. Palestinian guerrillas attacked Jewish settlements. The Haganah, the Etzel and Lehi fought loosely organized Palestinian forces. Thirty-five soldiers were lost defending the Etzion bloc.

On November 30, an ambush of a bus near Lod left five Jewish passengers dead. The Arab Higher Committee called a three-day strike on December 2. Palestinian forces lacked a central command, and their offensive was largely repelled. Arab forces controlled key highways and choked supply lines to Jewish communities in Jerusalem and the Negev. The first major Haganah attack came on December 12 at Balad al-Sheikh, near Haifa. The Haganah launched Operation Nachshon on April 5 to open the road to Jerusalem.

Plan Dalet was formally adopted on March 10. Its stated purpose was to secure the territory of the Jewish state and its lines of communication. That included offensive operations against Arab towns and villages.

Historians disagree about what the plan was. Walid Khalidi calls it a master plan for the conquest of Palestine. Ilan Pappé calls it premeditated ethnic cleansing. Benny Morris wrote in 1989 that the refugee problem was “born of war, not by design.” By 2004 he said the plan gave field commanders a strategic and ideological anchor they used to justify expulsions. Yoav Gelber argues the plan was defensive and aimed at villages that resisted. The Explaining History review of the debate says few historians share Gelber’s view.

On April 9, fighters of the Irgun and Lehi attacked Deir Yassin, an Arab village near Jerusalem. The attacking force numbered about 120. The casualty figures vary. An early claim put the dead at 254. Later counts are close to 100. The Israeli scholar Eliezer Tauber named 101 dead villagers. A Bir Zeit University study counted 107 civilians dead and 13 fighters.

The accounts also differ on how the villagers died. Tauber found no credible evidence of systematic slaughter, rape or torture. Looting occurred. The Jewish Agency condemned the attack and sent a letter of disapproval to King Abdullah of Transjordan.

Four days later, on April 13, Arab forces ambushed a convoy to the Hadassah hospital on Mount Scopus. About 80 Jews were killed, most of them medical personnel.

By mid-May, Jewish forces controlled the major cities and more than 100 Palestinian villages.

On May 14, in Tel Aviv, David Ben-Gurion proclaimed the State of Israel. The declaration cited the General Assembly resolution calling for a Jewish state. It offered peace to the neighboring states. It appealed to the Arab inhabitants of the new state to keep the peace on the basis of “full and equal citizenship.”

The next day the armies of Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and Iraq entered Palestine.

Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: 1948 Arab-Israeli War (November 30 bus ambush, December strike, Palestinian command structure, highways, Balad al-Sheikh, Lifta, Operation Nachshon, Deir Yassin and Hadassah convoy figures); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: UN Palestine Commission, First Monthly Report to the Security Council, January 26, 1948 (violence since December 1947, positions of the Arab Higher Committee and Jewish Agency, British position); Center for Online Judaic Studies: Jews killed between November 1947 and May 1948 (1,256 figure, first-week toll, incidents, historians cited); My Jewish Learning: Israel’s War of Independence (civil war phase, Etzion bloc, Deir Yassin, Hadassah convoy, control of cities and villages, Arab invasion); Explaining History: Plan Dalet, Military Strategy, Historiographical Debate and Political Controversy (adoption of Plan Dalet and the positions of Khalidi, Pappé, Morris and Gelber); Tablet: Remember Deir Yassin (attacking force, Tauber’s findings, 254 claim, looting); Jewish Virtual Library: The Capture of Deir Yassin (Bir Zeit count, Jewish Agency response); Avalon Project, Yale Law School: Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel (May 14, 1948 text)


THE ARMIES ENTER

On May 15, 1948, the Secretary-General of the Arab League cabled the United Nations. It said the Arab states were entering Palestine for the purpose of “restoring peace and security and establishing law and order in Palestine.” It said the Mandate had ended and left no legally constituted authority. It said Jewish aggression had displaced about 250,000 Arabs. It named Deir Yassin and Tiberias.

The cablegram stated a political aim as well. It called for a United State of Palestine on democratic principles. It said the Arab intervention would end once a sovereign Palestinian state could govern itself.

The Arab coalition was divided. A University of Oxford web text describes a secret meeting on November 17, 1947. Golda Meir met King Abdullah of Transjordan at Naharayim. By that account, they agreed to coordinate diplomatic and military strategy and to keep other Arab states out. Abdullah would absorb most of the territory designated for the Arab state. The text adds that the Mufti and Abdullah were rivals, and that Fawzi al-Qawuqji was hostile to the Mufti.

The size of the forces is also contested. The Israeli researcher Yigal Eilam writes that the two sides were about even. Once the Arab states entered, he says, each side put about 29,000 men in the field. He sets that against a Jewish community of 650,000 and an Arab world of 30 million. Eilam writes that the Israeli army tripled to more than 100,000 soldiers during the war, two-thirds of them recent immigrants. He credits Czech arms deliveries with building the Israeli air force and supplying rifles before Operation Nachshon.

The fighting moved in stages. On May 28, the Jewish Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem surrendered to the Arab Legion. A US vice consul in Jerusalem reported the numbers. About 2,000 women, children and elderly people were evacuated to the Jewish areas of the new city. The Red Cross supervised. About 300 men of military age were taken prisoner and sent to Amman. About 150 wounded were reported as well. The vice consul reported that about 900 Jews remained in the Old City while the evacuation was under way.

The Security Council adopted a four-week truce on May 29. On July 9, the Arab League rejected the Mediator’s proposal to extend it. Its reply said Zionist forces had violated the truce, smuggled in immigrants and arms, and burned villages. It said extending the truce would entrench the status quo.

The war then resumed. Israeli operations followed. Operation Dani took Lod and Ramle. Operation Hiram secured the Galilee. Operations Yoav and Horev expelled Egyptian forces by December. Operation Uvda took Eilat in March 1949.

Four armistice agreements ended the fighting. Egypt and Israel signed on February 24, 1949. Lebanon and Israel signed on March 23. Jordan and Israel signed on April 3. Syria and Israel signed on July 20.

Each agreement carried a clause protecting the parties’ positions on a final settlement. The Egyptian agreement said the line was not to be construed in any sense as a political or territorial boundary. The Jordanian agreement protected the residents of certain villages along the line. It guaranteed them full rights of residence, property and freedom, with compensation for any who left. The Egyptian agreement contained no provision on refugees. The Syrian agreement created a demilitarized zone between the armistice line and the international boundary.

Israel held 77 to 78 percent of Palestine, depending on the count, against 56 percent allocated in the partition plan. Between 5,700 and 6,400 Jews were killed, about 1 percent of the population. Between 10,000 and 15,000 Palestinian Arabs were killed. About 1,400 Egyptian soldiers were also killed, along with hundreds of soldiers from each of the Jordanian, Iraqi and Syrian armies and dozens of Lebanese. Each group lost roughly 1 percent of its population.

On the Arab side, the territories that remained went separate ways. On December 1, 1948, about 1,000 delegates met at Jericho under the mayor of Hebron, Muhammad Ali Ja’bari. They voted unanimously to unite with Jordan and proclaimed Abdullah king of all Palestine. They rejected the Gaza-based All-Palestine Government that the Arab Higher Committee backed. Jordan’s parliament ratified the resolutions on December 13. Egypt opposed the union. Britain approved it.

Jordan formally annexed the West Bank on April 24, 1950. The Arab League disapproved but took no action. West Bank Palestinians became Jordanian subjects without the full citizenship held by Abdullah’s subjects east of the river.

Sources: UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Cablegram dated 15 May 1948 from the Secretary-General of the Arab League (stated reasons for intervention, 250,000 figure, call for a United State of Palestine); Israel and the Arab Coalition in 1948, University of Oxford (Meir-Abdullah meeting, Abdullah’s aims, rivalries within the Arab coalition); PIJ: The Myth of the Few Against the Many in 1948, Yigal Eilam (troop numbers, Israeli mobilization, Czech arms); US Department of State, Foreign Relations of the United States 1948, vol. V, part 2: telegram of May 29, 1948 on the Jewish Quarter (surrender of the Jewish Quarter, evacuation and prisoner figures); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Telegram from the UN Mediator dated 9 July 1948 (Arab League rejection of truce extension); My Jewish Learning: Israel’s War of Independence (operations, territory, Israeli dead); Encyclopaedia Britannica: 1948 Arab-Israeli War (territory held, Jewish, Arab and army casualty ranges); Avalon Project, Yale Law School: Egyptian-Israeli General Armistice Agreement (February 24, 1949; boundary and refugee provisions); Avalon Project, Yale Law School: Lebanese-Israeli General Armistice Agreement (March 23, 1949); Avalon Project, Yale Law School: Jordanian-Israeli General Armistice Agreement (April 3, 1949; village provision); Avalon Project, Yale Law School: Israeli-Syrian General Armistice Agreement (July 20, 1949; demilitarized zone); Encyclopedia.com: Jericho Congress (1948) (December 1948 congress, ratification, Egyptian and British reactions); EBSCO Research Starters: Jordan Annexes West Bank (April 24, 1950 annexation, Arab League reaction, status of West Bank Palestinians)


THE FLIGHT AND THE EXPULSIONS

The number of Palestinians who left is a range. Nearly 1.4 million Arabs lived in Palestine before the war. Estimates of the number displaced between December 1947 and January 1949 run from about 520,000 to about 1,000,000. The consensus is above 600,000 and likely above 700,000.

The United Nations produced several estimates. On October 18, 1948, the acting UN Mediator raised his figure for Arab refugees from 360,000 to 472,000. He expected it to pass 500,000. On August 20, 1949, a technical committee of the UN Conciliation Commission reported an estimate of about 711,000 refugees from Israeli-held territory. The UN Statistical Office prepared it. The committee said earlier estimates differed partly because of definitions. Some counts included duplicate ration cards and destitute people who had not been displaced.

The Israeli historian Benny Morris sets the departures between November 1947 and October 1950 at 600,000 to 760,000.

About 276,000 moved to the West Bank. Between 160,000 and 190,000 went to Gaza. About 100,000 went to Lebanon and 100,000 to Jordan. Between 75,000 and 90,000 went to Syria. More than 400 Palestinian towns and villages were destroyed or depopulated, and more than 500 when temporary encampments are included.

The departures began early. Lifta, in west Jerusalem, was one of the first Arab villages emptied, in January 1948. Jewish forces took Tiberias on April 18, Haifa on April 21 and 22, Safed on May 10 and Jaffa on May 13. By mid-May, some 250,000 to 300,000 Palestinians had left or been expelled. The Arab armies did not enter until May 15.

Why they left is disputed. The UN Mediator’s report of September 16, 1948 named three causes of the Arab departure. They were panic created by the fighting, rumors of real or alleged acts of terrorism, and expulsion. The Israeli account holds that residents of Tiberias, Haifa and Safed fled despite Jewish authorities urging them to stay. A further Israeli claim held that Arab leaders had ordered the exodus by radio broadcast.

Walid Khalidi, a Palestinian historian, tested that claim in 1959. He reported that no such order appeared in four places. They were the Arab League’s press releases, its Assembly minutes, an Iraqi parliamentary inquiry and BBC monitoring records of Arab broadcasts. He also examined three Arab newspapers. He wrote that “There were no evacuation orders.” He cites Arab Higher Committee statements urging people to hold their ground. He cites Lebanese and Egyptian measures that turned back men of fighting age. He also cites a leaflet signed “Haganah Commander in Galilee,” reported by the Beirut daily al-Hayat on May 16, 1948. It told those who did not want the war to leave with their women and children. Khalidi calls such broadcasts part of a Zionist psychological offensive.

The Journal of Palestine Studies reprinted Khalidi’s article in 2005. Its editors quote Morris’s 2004 conclusions in the introduction. They say his 1986 book discredited the Israeli claim. They say his 2004 edition adds a finding. Local Arab commanders and officials advised or ordered many women, children and elderly people out of combat zones before battle was joined. Morris also found Arab leaders trying to keep men of fighting age in place.

Morris spoke to the Israeli newspaper Haaretz in an interview with Ari Shavit. He said there was “no explicit order of his in writing” from Ben-Gurion. He said there was an atmosphere of transfer from April 1948.

Lydda and Ramle are a specific case. Operation Dani began on July 9. The Israel Defense Forces took Lod and Ramla, two Arab cities inside the Arab state in the partition plan. Morris says the expulsion order for Lod was signed by Yitzhak Rabin. He says it was issued right after Ben-Gurion visited the headquarters of the operation. He describes a column of 50,000 people expelled from Lod walking east. He lists Lod among the worst massacres of the war, with 250 killed. He counts 24 massacres in all.

In 1979, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported on a New York Times story about Rabin’s memoirs. The story said the original manuscript described the expulsion of 50,000 Arab civilians from Lod and Ramla on Ben-Gurion’s orders. It said Israeli censors had cut the passage before publication. The Israeli general Yigal Allon denied it. He said “Ben-Gurion gave no such order.” Rabin declined to discuss the report. He said Israeli law barred him.

Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: 1948 Arab-Israeli War (population before the war, displacement range and consensus, destinations, number of villages, Lifta, dates of the fall of the mixed towns, mid-May figure, Lod and Ramla, Israeli perspective on Haifa and Safed); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Assistance to Refugees, UN Acting Mediator, Supplement to Progress Report, A/689, October 18, 1948 (360,000 and 472,000 estimates); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Report of the Technical Committee on Refugees to the Conciliation Commission, August 20, 1949 (711,000 estimate, definitions); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Progress Report of the United Nations Mediator on Palestine, A/648, September 16, 1948 (causes of the Arab departure); Benny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited, introduction (600,000 to 760,000 range); Walid Khalidi, Why Did the Palestinians Leave, Revisited, Journal of Palestine Studies, vol. 34, no. 2 (Winter 2005), pp. 42-54 (1959 article, editors’ introduction, Arab-side records, Haifa communiqués, Galilee leaflet); Logos Journal: Ari Shavit, Survival of the Fittest? An Interview with Benny Morris (Ben-Gurion and transfer, Lod expulsion order, Lod column, massacre counts); Detroit Jewish News, November 2, 1979, JTA report on Rabin’s memoirs (censored manuscript, Allon’s denial, Rabin’s response)


THE DOOR CLOSED

On September 16, 1948, the UN Mediator, Count Folke Bernadotte, filed his progress report. He recommended that the United Nations affirm the right of the refugees to return to their homes at the earliest practicable date. He recommended compensation for those who chose not to return.

The next day, September 17, Bernadotte was shot dead in the Katamon district of Jerusalem. Lehi carried out the killing. The gunman was Yehoshua Cohen. A French UN observer, Andre Seraut, was killed with him. The Israeli government then cracked down on Lehi, arrested many of its members and seized its arms. Lehi disbanded.

On December 11, the General Assembly adopted Resolution 194. Paragraph 11 addressed refugees wishing to return and live at peace with their neighbors. They “should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date.” Compensation should be paid for the property of those who chose not to return. It should also cover loss of or damage to property. The resolution told a new Conciliation Commission to facilitate repatriation, resettlement, rehabilitation and compensation.

At the Lausanne talks, Israel made two proposals. A Conciliation Commission working paper of May 15, 1950 records them. Israel proposed to annex the Gaza Strip and give citizenship to its inhabitants, including the refugees. It later offered to accept the return of 80,000 refugees. It reserved its position on that offer.

Its general position was firmer. On July 28, 1949, an Israeli representative, G. Merom, gave the commission’s technical committee a memorandum. It said “The clock cannot be put back.” It said the former Arab economy had ceased to exist. Any refugees allowed back would be treated as new immigrants. They would be absorbed in groups.

The legal framework followed in 1950. The Knesset passed the Absentees’ Property Law on March 14. It defined an absentee as an owner or holder of property after November 29, 1947. The owner had to be a national of one of seven named Arab states or be outside Israel. It also covered a Palestinian who had left home for a place outside Palestine before September 1, 1948. It covered a Palestinian who had gone to a place in Palestine held by forces seeking to prevent the creation of Israel. The law vested such property in a Custodian. It allowed the Custodian to sell it to a Development Authority at not less than its official value.

On July 5, the Knesset passed the Law of Return. Its first section says “Every Jew has the right to come to this country as an oleh.” A visa could be refused for activity against the Jewish people. It could also be refused if the applicant was likely to endanger public health or state security. A 1970 amendment extended the right to a Jew’s child, grandchild and spouse.

About 500,000 Palestinians qualified for UN relief when the United Nations Relief and Works Agency began operating in 1950. The number reached 6,000,000 by the 2020s, counting descendants.

Crossings of the armistice lines were a separate issue. The Israeli researcher Shaul Bartal, writing for the BESA Center, reports about 70,000 infiltration cases between 1949 and 1956. He cites Benny Morris for 317 Jewish deaths from infiltrators, mostly from Gaza. In a review of Morris’s study of the border, Avi Shlaim writes that Morris found 90 percent or more of infiltrations were economic or social. The motives included returning to homes, recovering possessions and harvesting crops. Shlaim reports that Israeli forces killed between 2,700 and 5,000 infiltrators, most of them unarmed. He cites the Qibya raid of October 1953, in which 69 Jordanians were killed, most of them women and children.

Inside Israel, Arab citizens lived under military government. It covered about 85 percent of Arab citizens. Commanders could declare closed zones that required written permits. Regulations also allowed administrative detention and deportation. Its aims were preventing infiltration, settlement in abandoned villages and refugee returns. Prime Minister Levi Eshkol announced its end in 1966.

On October 29, 1956, a border patrol shot dead 49 villagers at Kafr Qasim, 23 of them children. The curfew had been moved from 9 p.m. to 5 p.m. at 1 p.m. that day. Many villagers were in the fields and had not heard. The commander, Issachar Shadmi, was fined one hundredth of an Israeli lira. Eight of 11 soldiers received long sentences and went free within a year.

Sources: UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Progress Report of the United Nations Mediator on Palestine, A/648, September 16, 1948 (recommendation on return and compensation); Jewish Virtual Library: The Assassination of Count Bernadotte (September 17, 1948 killing, Lehi, Seraut, government crackdown); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Historical Survey of Efforts of the Conciliation Commission to Implement Paragraph 11 of Resolution 194 (III), A/AC.25/W/82/Rev.1 (text of paragraph 11 and the Commission’s mandate); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Conciliation Commission Working Paper A/AC.25/W/45, May 15, 1950 (Lausanne proposals on Gaza and 80,000 refugees); UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Report of the Technical Committee on Refugees, August 20, 1949 (Israeli memorandum of July 28, 1949); Adalah: Absentees’ Property Law, 5710-1950 (text, definition of absentee, Custodian, Development Authority); Adalah: Law of Return, 1950 (sections 1 and 2, 1970 amendment); Encyclopaedia Britannica: 1948 Arab-Israeli War (UNRWA registration and growth); BESA Center: Shaul Bartal, After the War (infiltration cases and Israeli deaths); Avi Shlaim: Israel’s Dirty War, review of Benny Morris, Israel’s Border Wars (infiltrator motives, infiltrators killed, Qibya); Akevot Institute: Military Government Over Arab Citizens of Israel (share of population, closed zones, regulations, aims); Economic Cooperation Foundation: Abolition of the Military Governance of Arab-Populated Areas in Israel (1966) (end of military government, Eshkol notice); The Conversation: Remembering the Palestinians Murdered at Kafr Qasim (October 29, 1956 killings, curfew, sentences)


THE OTHER EXODUS

The United Nations counted Jewish refugees as well. A supplement from the UN Acting Mediator, dated October 18, 1948, put them at 7,000. It said later representations from Israeli authorities had not changed that figure.

A second movement came from the Arab world. About 851,000 Jews lived in eight Arab countries in 1948. Morocco had 265,000. Algeria had 140,000. Iraq had 135,000. Tunisia had 105,000. Egypt had 75,000. Yemen and Aden had 63,000. Libya had 38,000. Syria had 30,000.

About 820,000 left between 1948 and 1972. Of those, 586,000 went to Israel and more than 200,000 went to Europe and North America. The World Union for Progressive Judaism, a non-governmental body, gives a higher figure for Israel. Its 2003 submission to the United Nations puts the number integrated there at more than 650,000. By 2018, 3,330 Jews remained in those countries.

The departures differed by country. Yemen’s Jews were flown out of the British colony of Aden. The American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee organized and financed the airlift, which it calls the largest in history. It counts almost 49,000 people between December 1948 and September 1950. All but about 1,000 of Yemen’s 45,000 Jews came to Israel by the end of 1951.

Iraq’s exodus came in 1950 and 1951. Almost 120,000 Jews left in an airlift known as Operation Ezra and Nehemiah. A 1951 law froze the assets of Jews who left after 1948. It also revoked their citizenship. By the end of 1951, 121,512 of Iraq’s 130,000 Jews had arrived in Israel.

Bombings targeted Jews in Baghdad during the same period. The first, in April 1950, hit a café Jews frequented. They resumed in 1951. Who carried them out is disputed, and so is their part in the exodus. The London Review of Books published an exchange of letters in 2008. Lyn Julius wrote that 60,000 Iraqi Jews had registered to leave before the only fatal bombing, in January 1951. She named restrictions on education, travel and work as the causes. Adam Shatz replied that Israeli intelligence promoted emigration. He wrote that Mossad’s man in Baghdad, Shlomo Hillel, worked to bring about mass departure. Shatz also wrote “We may never know whether the bombs were laid by Zionist agents.”

Libya and North Africa also sent large numbers. By the end of 1951, 30,500 of Libya’s 35,000 Jews had arrived in Israel. So had 45,400 from Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria.

The Jewish population of Israel roughly doubled. About 650,000 Jews lived in Israel at its founding. Some 688,000 arrived in the first three and a half years. In the first year alone, 203,000 arrived from 42 countries. The share of Asian and African-born people among Israel’s foreign-born rose from 15.1 percent in November 1948 to 36.9 percent by the end of 1951.

Of 393,197 immigrants who arrived between May 1948 and May 1950, 123,669 were housed in homes abandoned by Arabs. By May 1952 there were 113 transit camps, called ma’abarot, with a population of 250,000.

Jonathan Kaplan writes that the state faced many arrivals who lacked agricultural or modern professional skills. He says 16 percent of arrivals aged 15 and over had finished secondary school, against 34 percent of earlier settlers.

The Jewish Virtual Library says the immigrants were absorbed without compensation from the Arab governments that confiscated their possessions.

Sources: UN Information System on the Question of Palestine: Assistance to Refugees, UN Acting Mediator, Supplement to Progress Report, A/689, October 18, 1948 (figure of 7,000 Jewish refugees); Jewish Virtual Library: Jewish Refugees from Arab Countries (1948 populations by country, departures, destinations, 2018 figure, compensation); World Union for Progressive Judaism, UN document E/CN.4/Sub.2/2003/NGO/35, March 17, 2003 (integration figure); American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee Archives: Operation Magic Carpet (Yemen airlift organization, dates and count); US National Archives: Iraqi Jewish Archive, After Millennia (Operation Ezra and Nehemiah, 1951 law, citizenship and assets); Jewish Agency for Israel: Independent Israel, Aliyah and Absorption (arrivals by country, first-year figure, housing in abandoned homes, transit camps); London Review of Books, Letters, vol. 30, no. 23 (2008) (Julius and Shatz exchange on Iraq); London Review of Books: Adam Shatz, Leaving Paradise, vol. 30, no. 21 (2008) (April 1950 café bombing, bombings resuming in 1951, disputed responsibility); My Jewish Learning: The Mass Migration to Israel of the 1950s, Jonathan Kaplan (arrivals, population at founding, North African figures, shift in composition, skills and schooling)


Part Three picks up in 1967. It covers the Six-Day War, Security Council Resolution 242 and the competing readings of its text, and the first settlements, including the warning from Israel’s own legal adviser. It runs through the PLO charter, the wars of 1973 and 1982, and the 1988 proclamation of a Palestinian state.